bit-gamer.net

Sony to sue over Change4Life UK ad?

Sony to sue over Change4Life UK ad?

The new Change4Life campaign shows a PS3 controller and implies games can cause health issues.

Sony has voiced a possible intention to pursue legal action against the Change4Life campaign in the UK after a new advertising scheme apparently points the finger at videogaming as a major cause of health issues.

Sony apparently feels that it is being singled out by the campaign too, which shows a controller being used by a young boy alongside text that reads 'Risk an early death, just doing nothing'. The controller bears a remarkable resemblance to a PS3 controller.

The Change4Life campaign is a new scheme that attempts to tackle the issue of child obesity, diabetes, heart disease and cancer. It has been using a run of national magazine adverts to try and promote an active lifestyle in children.

Sony is apparently worried however that the campaign is drawing a direct correlation between the PlayStation and these health-issues, as although the controller depicted is apparently not an official Sony controller, it does bear a resemblance. Check out the full advert here.

According to MCV Sony may be looking to pursue legal action on the basis that the controller patent may be infringed, as the advertising agency did not seek permission to use the controller in the advert.

Is Sony over-reacting, or is the company right to object to the way the advert draws a relationship between games and poor health? Let us know what you think in the forums.

24 Comments

Discuss in the forums Reply
UrbanMarine 10th March 2009, 12:31 Quote
Woohoo another lawsuit to pay the bills.
Bauul 10th March 2009, 12:39 Quote
I agree with Change4Life, everyone knows Playstations kill you.

Is it just me, or does Change4Life sound like some awful pacifist Left4Dead mod? You go around hugging zombies and encouraging them to express themselves creatively, thus restoring elements of their previous lives.
Jamie 10th March 2009, 12:44 Quote
They should use positive images to promote active lifestyles rather than negative images such as these.
nukeman8 10th March 2009, 12:52 Quote
kid looks quite happy to me in that picture lol.
but yes postive images are better, advert with a kid playing a pc is much more creative.
Neoki 10th March 2009, 13:07 Quote
To be fair this is a good ad, basicly says PS3 gives you health problems but 360 dont :p (Commence fan boy attack)

The sofa looks pretty cool though.
Zut 10th March 2009, 13:54 Quote
Hey kids! Don't play games or read books or do anything that challenges you mentally. Just go outside and flap your arms about, to make sure you live as long as possible.

Why the HELL would I want to live longer if I cant play games? I'd rather die happy at 50 than live to be an abstinent, joyless 90 year old husk.
Paradigm Shifter 10th March 2009, 14:27 Quote
Persuading kids (and parents) that actually going out and getting some exercise and also eating healthily - cutting down on the supermarket ready meals or take-aways and actually buying raw meat and veg and cooking themselves - would have more of an impact than this.

In all honesty, given some of the extremely large groups of kids wondering around my neighbourhood over the last few years, I'd rather they were home playing games than just wondering down the street swilling from a can of beer and attempting to get that crown of disaffected teen life - the ASBO.

Besides... the same argument can be used against reading or studying - you're sitting there not getting any exercise... you should be outside! Pfft. Yeah, like the youth in Britain aren't already illiterate enough.
D3s3rt_F0x 10th March 2009, 15:25 Quote
Guns dont kill people, playstations do
UrbanMarine 10th March 2009, 15:30 Quote
Playstation 3s are heavy enough to kill someone. Oh no better recall all the systems for deadly weight issues.
Psytek 10th March 2009, 15:40 Quote
Kinda sad that parents need to be told that their kids need exercise in the first place. But this is really not the way to do it.
s3v3n 10th March 2009, 16:05 Quote
He's only unhappy because he's playing on a Playstation!! Get him an xbox or Wii and he'll look like Joe.

j/k btw. I a PS3 myself and not a 360/Wii lol
Zero_UK 10th March 2009, 16:52 Quote
Bit off topic but I reckon Change4Life will be going on about how previous generations would play outside etc go to the park yet now because of computers where all staying inside. Well times change, you cant go out and play in the park as you used to be able to as threes so many sick *******s around that kids get kidnapped, people kicking a balls around or what ever get stuff shouted at them by other kids or get picked on etc. I used to enjoy BMX'ing, yet you slowly grow tried of being chased by gangs and crap, enjoyed playing with BB guns - someone calls the police saying some kids are planning a terrorist attack - armed police come raiding us lol.

And all that.. in not bad areas.. so I dread to think what its like in worse areas. So many of the young generation now are arseholes no matter where you are.

And people wonder why kids prefer to stay in doors? lol - should have brought more healthy eating into it, maybe parents walking kids to school or what ever. - How about parents bringing kids out on walks lol? bring them some place interesting.
Nicb 10th March 2009, 17:47 Quote
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jamie
They should use positive images to promote active lifestyles rather than negative images such as these.

Your right!! I can't believe these AD guys are so stupid. These type of Ads just puts up a brick wall and a ton of excuses. Everybody loves "something" that has to do with outdoors and exercise. Take the kid out to do what ever you know he's interested in with friends. If he notices he can't keep up with the others his age he will think to him self "Man, I need to get out more, I'm pathetic." Then you never have to shove exercise down his throat with words,... never works.
leexgx 10th March 2009, 23:32 Quote
Please remove intll pop up text adds or I just block all adds on this web site I am on google phone so its quite annoying when useing this web site
Perforated 11th March 2009, 00:24 Quote
Meh, I don't think the ad's at such fault. Giving parents that vague association that "if your kid's always sat on the sofa, he ain't gonna work off lunch" is no bad thing. Any parent that summarily bans their kids from playing games as a result has missed the point by such a margin that the kid's probably already pretty condemned by their genes. It even specifies in the ad "active for an hour a day". After which, they can sit on the sofa murdering hookers for as long as they like.

There ARE positive association ads running as well, this is supplementary. Sony are just stomping their feet because it's a PS controller and they think people are going to think their console is more murderous than MS or Ninty's, obviously (!). Frankly, anybody that can recognise it as a PS controller has more than likely had enough exposure to them to realise they're not poisonous, or going to randomly explode or anything (Sony limit that to their laptop cells, you see, it's a USP).
FIBRE+ 11th March 2009, 01:26 Quote
It's the parents fault in most cases, using the baby sitter (TV, computer, console) instead of actually taking the kids out to the park or whatever. I think parents just want too much now, both have full time jobs, both have social lives and expect those 10 minutes they spend with there kids to make a fully rounded adult one day. Having kids for there own benefeit rather than the kids, "everyone else has one, we don't want to be left out!". It's just another case of blaming gaming\music\tv\film instead of the society, it's easyer that way as most people will agree.

If parents need to be told about simple things like this they're not fit for the job in the first place, saying that though those same people probably thought it was a maturing beer gut rather than a growing baby...

http://img.thesun.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00487/Wayne_Slob_487012a.jpg
docodine 11th March 2009, 06:42 Quote
Obviously they had to use a PS controller, nobody can look that depressed with a Wiimote in hand..
DriftCarl 11th March 2009, 07:38 Quote
I thought I read not long ago that your average gamer is actually slimmer than your average binge drinker, and that gamers are actually quite healthy.

Standing there playing the wii wwith your mates is quite a workout, as is jumping around on hard mode on guitar hero.

I would suggest to parents to walk your kids to school rather than fill up the roads at rush hour with your useless 4x4 landrovers.
bigsharn 11th March 2009, 09:43 Quote
Quote:
Originally Posted by DriftCarl
I thought I read not long ago that your average gamer is actually slimmer than your average binge drinker, and that gamers are actually quite healthy.

I was just going to mention this... excluding myself I've never met a fat gamer (and mine comes from years of drinking fizzy drinks and not exercising), but I suppose my love for Guinness isn't helping a great deal
badders 11th March 2009, 09:53 Quote
Quote:
Originally Posted by DriftCarl


Standing there playing the wii wwith your mates is quite a workout, as is jumping around on hard mode on guitar hero.

Hmm, If you can do this without feeling like a tit and not drinking, then there may be something wrong with you.
Xir 11th March 2009, 13:08 Quote
Quote:
Originally Posted by Perforated
After which, they can sit on the sofa murdering hookers for as long as they like.

Which is quite an excercise by itself, as they tend to run away...besides, after the first one bloodstained your sofa, it's WORK to get anotherone into knife-range...

...or wasn't this what you meant?

Back to Topic:
I for one definitely need to get out more :)
Perforated 11th March 2009, 16:37 Quote
No, that's pretty much what I meant :) The trick is to get their head down first, then they don't see you pull the knife from behind the cushion. Pay the extra, it's not like she takes it with her.
Major 11th March 2009, 16:44 Quote
Silly campaign, waste of money, something like £75m is being spent on this crap?

You want to be fit? Go for a run and eat decently, the Government know nothing regarding fitness and think employing silly celebrities will fix the nations problems. People get fat because they eat the wrong foods and don't workout, so, what do you do to get fit? Do the exact opposite of how you got fat.

Now people do need educating regarding the whole fitness thing, what carbs and sugars you can't eat, how many carbs you need to eat a day, how much meat you need to eat, protein, how much you need to workout, and different intensity means different time limits etc. That needs to be sorted out via the internet IMO. All the information is there already for free on many bodybuilding websites (and they are the only websites you will find decent information on for free because they are packed full of people who live to be fit).

The problem is finding the information, and if you don't have enough knoweldge on the subject, then you just won't find it.

Heh, I sit on my ass all day playing games some days, but I'm still fit and eat decent.
Xir 15th March 2009, 19:32 Quote
Quote:
Originally Posted by Perforated
No, that's pretty much what I meant :) The trick is to get their head down first, then they don't see you pull the knife from behind the cushion. Pay the extra, it's not like she takes it with her.

fantastic! :D
Log in

You are not logged in, please login with your forum account below. If you don't already have an account please register to start contributing.



Discuss in the forums

More About...