Xbox 360 HDD loading gives minimal benefits

The New Xbox Experience may offer the option to run games from the hard drive, but speed isn't massively improved by it.

According to Eurogamer who took it upon themselves to test the New Xbox Experience, loading games from the Xbox 360 hard drive doesn't always offer improved load times in games.

The New Xbox Experience is part of a major Xbox 360 update that will soon be released by Microsoft. The update will completely overhaul the Xbox 360 interface, as well as bringing wholly new features - most importantly the option to run games from the Xbox 360 hard drive. Oh, and there''s also that avatar system that Microsoft claims to have invented as well.

With many gamers getting regular disc read errors from their noisy old Xbox 360 disc drives, the option to run from the disc is eagerly awaited.

Unfortunately though comparisons from Eurogamer reveal that the load times for most games aren't massively improved. While some titles like Valve's Orange Box have load times that are substantially decreased, the bulk of games show little to no improvement - including titles like Halo 3.

The reason for the lack of improvement is, we reckon, quite simply that many Xbox 360 games (particularly exclusives) were designed to run only from the optical drive and are therefore unable to take advantage of any speed increases the hard drive might offer. Games that were ported from PC however, such as The Orange Box, are more adaptable to running from the hard drive and can therefore harness the extra power.

The comparison did note however that running from the hard drive eliminated the noise coming from the revving disc drive, so it isn't all bad.

Have you had disc read errors and red rings on your Xbox 360? Let us know in the forums.
Quote Chr!s 12th November 2008, 09:59
Quote:
The comparison did note however that running from the hard drive eliminated the noise coming from the revving disc drive, so it isn't all bad.

All that matters..
Quote cjoyce1980 12th November 2008, 10:17
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chr!s
Quote:
The comparison did note however that running from the hard drive eliminated the noise coming from the revving disc drive, so it isn't all bad.

All that matters..

to right........ as long as i can store 3-4 games on there that i play the most.... i dont really care about loading times
Quote Kaboom22 12th November 2008, 10:28
Quote:
While some titles like Valve's Orange Box have load times that are substantially increased, the bulk of other games show little to no improvement

Shouldn't that be decreased?
Quote shigllgetcha 12th November 2008, 10:37
Quote:
Originally Posted by cjoyce1980
to right........ as long as i can store 3-4 games on there that i play the most.... i dont really care about loading times

yeh i read fable 2 took up 6.8GB when it was loaded.

all i want is a quieter 360 any decreased load times would be a bonus.

Would people assume that for games that were designed to run from optical drives it would be at too basic of a level for an update to change (ie would an update make them run off the hard drive faster)
Quote liratheal 12th November 2008, 10:43
Face meltingly expected.

Quieter drive is all I was after with this update. Which has been delivered. Win-win for me, at least.
Quote sandys 12th November 2008, 10:47
I'd say that 10-20 second improvements in the odd level and game load is a substantial improvement that along with the quieter playback is surely justification enough?
Quote LeMaltor 12th November 2008, 10:48
I too like to silence my 360 for upwards of 30 pounds.
Quote Jamie 12th November 2008, 11:05
I'm just looking forward to the silence and not getting disc read errors half way through games.
Quote mclean007 12th November 2008, 11:17
Quote:
Originally Posted by LeMaltor
I too like to silence my 360 for upwards of 30 pounds.
I don't follow?
Quote chiper136 12th November 2008, 11:27
The new interface looks nicer, and loading from the HDD is quieter. I honestly don't think anyone really had big enough issues about load times to care about it. If it loads faster its just icing on the cake.
Quote Veles 12th November 2008, 13:12
Yeah it's not really the load times I was worried about, but little things like Mass Effect not having the odd pause while it loads is still a really good thing IMO.

Odd how Crackdown doesn't support it.
Quote devdevil85 12th November 2008, 16:36
Quote:
Originally Posted by shigllgetcha
yeh i read fable 2 took up 6.8GB when it was loaded.
I know a lot of people with a 360 that can't even free up 3GB of their available 20GB (more like 17GB).....I wonder how many people will actually be able to use this feature? Honestly, I think it's great: 1) quieter console 2) faster load times. You can't beat that. That hard part is freeing up the space.
Quote Er-El 12th November 2008, 16:54
As long as I don't have to hear a harrier jet taking off in the background and I can rest assured that my game disc won't get scratched for the umpteenth time, then I'm happy.
Quote mikeuk2004 12th November 2008, 18:20
Quote:
Originally Posted by devdevil85
I know a lot of people with a 360 that can't even free up 3GB of their available 20GB (more like 17GB).....I wonder how many people will actually be able to use this feature? Honestly, I think it's great: 1) quieter console 2) faster load times. You can't beat that. That hard part is freeing up the space.

After the 20gb is formated im sure I only had around 14gb to start with anyway.

I have loads of games on mine from the live arcade, inc map packs, GH III tracks etc for example R6V is £1.2gb Halo 3 over 1GB.

Im trying to free up enough space to download GTA SA which aint going to happen. Installing a game on my HD is not going to happen. I dont see the point anyway.
Quote talladega 12th November 2008, 20:46
buy a 120gb for $100

I think its great about it making it not sound like an aircraft taking off but I just wonder about the heat.

Wasnt RROD often caused by overheating? The DVD drive just made noise. It doenst really produce heat. But constantly reading off the HDD will produce alot of heat. Would this not greatly increase the chance of RROD?
Quote notatoad 12th November 2008, 21:38
Quote:
Originally Posted by talladega
But constantly reading off the HDD will produce alot of heat.

the hdd is nowhere near the chips, off in it's own little compartment on the top. shouldn't affect system temps at all.
Quote capnPedro 12th November 2008, 22:48
I have ~100GB free. Woo! :D
Quote PhenomRed 13th November 2008, 05:24
can't wait, when i play Fable II i gat a constant revving noise from the optical drive, and gets laggy and unresponsive at times. hopefully this will fix that.

anyone else having this problem?
Quote talladega 13th November 2008, 05:45
Quote:
Originally Posted by supertoad
the hdd is nowhere near the chips, off in it's own little compartment on the top. shouldn't affect system temps at all.
Well that's good then. Because I know the 360 has a piss poor cooling system so that extra heat would make a big difference. But since it's it its own compartment thing as you say then it shouldn't affect it. That would be horrible for MS if it did though.
Log in

You are not logged in, please login with your forum account below. If you don't already have an account please register to start contributing.







Mobile Phones

LG Arena ReviewHTC Magic Review

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!



Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 broadband & mobile broadband deals online!

Dragonage