Microsoft refuses US email data order

Microsoft refuses US email data order

Microsoft has indicated that it is refusing a court order to turn over foreign-held email data to the US government, pending a second appeal against the ruling

Microsoft has indicated that it has no intentions of complying with a US court order to turn over email data held on foreign servers, despite having lost its appeal against the order.

The US government has been attempting to order Microsoft to turn over customer data held on its Dublin-based servers for some time, with the company appealing against the order with the claim that the Fourth Amendment to the US constitution - protection against physical searches outside the US - should apply. In August, the courts ruled against Microsoft and once again ordered Microsoft to cough up the data. The argument was simple: while the data, and even the targeted customer, may be outside the US, Microsoft itself operates within the US and therefore is subject to US law.

That could have been the end of it, but Microsoft isn't going down without a fight. A company spokesperson has told Reuters that it 'will not be turning over the email,' and that it plans to take its appeal to a higher court. 'Everyone agrees that this case can and will proceed to the appeals court,' the spokesperson said. 'This is simply about finding the appropriate procedure for that to happen.'

Until that procedure is found and Microsoft's appeal can be formally lodged, it technically stands in contempt of court by refusing to provide the data. If it caves and turns over the emails, however, it could risk severely damaging consumer confidence in the very concept of cloud-based data storage and application provision - a major blow for its Azure, OneDrive, Outlook and Office 365 products.


Discuss in the forums Reply
Corky42 1st September 2014, 11:45 Quote
Governments and TPTB should be treating data in the same way as real world psychical objects, and/or people, just because data can be accessed from remote locations shouldn't mean local, and international laws can conveniently be ignored.

It's high time that governments do something to protect the public's privacy and civil liberties online, instead of the constant erosion that we have seen over the last few years.
jrs77 1st September 2014, 12:34 Quote
USoA violating privacy-rights and not giving a **** about foreign country laws... nothing new.
Fizzban 1st September 2014, 20:17 Quote
Go Microsoft! Tell those buggers where to go. ;)
RichCreedy 1st September 2014, 20:28 Quote
Microsoft could just sell its foreign datacentres to Franchisers and say, oops sorry we don't have control over them.

except maybe the Chinese ones :wink: :wink: :nudge: :nudge:
somidiot 2nd September 2014, 20:17 Quote
Really the data IS a physical object. It's physically arranged electrons on a physical disk. Just because you can easily copy it somewhere doesn't mean it's not physical.

It is disappointing that the U.S. is perusing this like this. One of the few times where I'm rooting for Microsoft.
Log in

You are not logged in, please login with your forum account below. If you don't already have an account please register to start contributing.

Discuss in the forums