Microsoft appeal against XML patent fails

Microsoft appeal against XML patent fails

The ability to save or read custom XML in Word 2007 will be removed from January 11 2010 - and Microsoft owes patent holder I4i serious money.

Microsoft has lost its appeal following a case in which it was found guilty of infringing a patent on XML support - and faces an injunction on the sale of its Office suite as a result.

As reported over on CNet, the case - brought against Microsoft by I4i back in May - accused Microsoft of infringing a patent with its support for custom XML in Word, which affected the opening and saving of .XML, .DOCM, and .DOCX files. Although Microsoft fought the accusations, a jury found the company in breach of patent law - which was immediately appealed.

Sadly for Microsoft, that appeal has now also failed - and an injunction enforced which will force the company to stop selling Microsoft Office 2007 from the 11th of January next year unless the infringing code is removed.

Although Office 2010 - the next release of the popular productivity suite - does not infringe the patent, the deadline means that Microsoft will be modifying Word 2007 to remove the ability to read and write custom XML to its files, which the company claims is a "little-used feature" anyway.

Kevin Kurtz, director of public affairs for Microsoft, said of the ruling that his company is "considering our legal options, which could include a request for a rehearing by the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals en banc or a request for a writ of certiorari from the U.S. Supreme Court" whilst "moving quickly to address the injunction issue."

The company would do well to find a loophole, and fast: as well as the injunction, the ruling leaves Microsoft liable for the original settlement of $200 million (£125 million) in damages plus interest and charges since the original case was lost in May - which some are estimating could end up boosting the figure to a whopping $290 million (£182 million).

Are you pleased to see Microsoft brought to task for blatant patent infringement, or do you believe that the company is innocent of the charges against it? Will Microsoft end up paying the penalty or finding a cheaper way to settle the disagreement? Has anybody even used the custom XML ability within Word 2007? Share your thoughts over in the forums.


Discuss in the forums Reply
Elton 23rd December 2009, 10:43 Quote
I use wordpad.

So no. Although I'm sure that the Custom XML works pretty well.
impar 23rd December 2009, 12:19 Quote

Microsoft is not blaming a third-party on this one?
Skiddywinks 23rd December 2009, 13:49 Quote
I don't even know what we are talking about here. XML? Never even heard of it used in Word.
eddtox 23rd December 2009, 14:15 Quote
Does anyone actually care? Getting a bit fed up of everyone taking a potshot at Microsoft right now. They actually seem to be producing some really good staff and everyone wants a piece of them. Cut them some slack and check out 7. :)
mctigger 23rd December 2009, 15:55 Quote
I occasionally output stuff to word/excel in XML using the SAS, not sure if that falls under custom XML or plain old XML, will be interesting to see
Log in

You are not logged in, please login with your forum account below. If you don't already have an account please register to start contributing.

Discuss in the forums