SATA SDHC RAID spotted

The device takes six SDHC cards and combines them in a SATA-presented RAID 0 array.

If you're looking to get in on the SSD market, but are looking for something a little more interesting than a drop-in drive replacement, how about a one-box SSD RAID system?

The PhotoFast CR-9000 device, spotted on Japanese website Impress by Gizmodo is a SATA-connected 2.5” device which takes up to SDHC flash memory cards and presents them to the host PC as a single logical drive.

Available in Japan at a price of ¥9,980 (about £48) the unit has a low entry cost so long as you've got a bunch of matching SDHC cards already lying around. While the performance can't match a custom-built drive, Impress were able to get a pretty impressive 111.4MB/s read and 55.2MB/s write when combining the device with six Transcend 8GB Class 6 SDHC cards.

Perhaps most interestingly is the lack of backwards compatibility on the drive itself – the device supports SDHC cards of 4GB or higher only, without the capability to utilise smaller SD cards that one would expect of an SDHC-aware device. I'm afraid that you'll have to find another use for those hundreds of 512MB and 1GB cards that seem to accumulate every time you buy a new gadget.

With the cost of real SSD drives dropping by the day – and the performance ever rising – I can't help but feel that this gadget serves more purpose as a proof-of-concept than a serious upgrade. I'm especially worried as to the idea of a RAID 0 array spanning six SDHC cards, with the knowledge that it only takes a single card's death to send all my precious data to the graveyard.

Can you think of a use for the CR-9000, or is it destined to be nothing more than a novelty for people with more SDHC cards than they know what to do with? Share your thoughts over in the forums.
Quote Icy EyeG 12th August 2008, 12:37
Quote:
Originally Posted by Article
The PhotoFast CR-9000 device, spotted on Japanese website Impress by Gizmodo is a SATA-connected 2.5” device which takes up to 6 SDHC flash memory cards and presents them to the host PC as a single logical drive.

;) I think the "6" is missing...
Quote WildThing 12th August 2008, 12:38
Cool nifty little gagdet, but nothing more I think. Like you say, RAID 0 with 6 SDHC cards, sounds dangerous!
Quote cjoyce1980 12th August 2008, 12:54
hopefully you should be able to recover the data on the other cards if one does die on you.

nice concept though
Quote Timmy_the_tortoise 12th August 2008, 13:01
6 SDHC Cards?

So, we're talking a maximum of 48GB using 8GB cards.. It's roughly £15 per card, that makes it £90... Then £48 for the unit..

We're talking £138 for 48GB of SSD storage, here.

Is that really worth it? I can see pretty much no point to this.
Quote Tyrmot 12th August 2008, 13:04
No option for anything else like RAID 5 then? That would certainly make it more tempting...
Quote TreeDude 12th August 2008, 13:11
Quote:
Originally Posted by cjoyce1980
hopefully you should be able to recover the data on the other cards if one does die on you.

nice concept though

It is a RAID 0. The data is broken up and striped across the drives. If you save a file, no matter what the size, pieces of that file will be on all the drives. That is how you get the increased read/write speeds. Trust me, if one drive goes, that is it for everything. Even using heavy recovery tools you would only be able to recover small system files that were smaller than the stripe size.
Quote naokaji 12th August 2008, 15:40
simply too slow to be worth it (ssd is faster, like for example ocz core) , besides, how reliable are SDHC cards? I doubt they have a very high mtbf if used 24/7.
Quote SixthEnigma 12th August 2008, 15:54
Raid Data Integrity -- If it weren't for the limitations of laptops, you could always fit two of these drives and set up raid mirroring between them :-)
Quote p3n 12th August 2008, 17:18
Quote:
Originally Posted by cjoyce1980
hopefully you should be able to recover the data on the other cards if one does die on you.

nice concept though

go lookup RAID 0 :)
Quote identikit 12th August 2008, 18:06
Quote:
Originally Posted by p3n
Quote:
Originally Posted by cjoyce1980
hopefully you should be able to recover the data on the other cards if one does die on you.

nice concept though

go lookup RAID 0 :)

Yep, people commonly refer to RAID 0 as "RAID 0; the number stands for how many files you'll get back if it fails"
Quote Cobalt 12th August 2008, 18:53
I'm not sure it should even be allowed to bear the "RAID" moniker. The R does stand for redundant y'know.
Quote Anakha 12th August 2008, 20:16
Quote:
Originally Posted by TreeDude
Quote:
Originally Posted by cjoyce1980
hopefully you should be able to recover the data on the other cards if one does die on you.

nice concept though

It is a RAID 0. The data is broken up and striped across the drives. If you save a file, no matter what the size, pieces of that file will be on all the drives. That is how you get the increased read/write speeds. Trust me, if one drive goes, that is it for everything. Even using heavy recovery tools you would only be able to recover small system files that were smaller than the stripe size.

And yes, you lose one "Disk", you lose everything. Just like a non-RAID1 or RAID5 system. Though if you can identify the bad "Disk", you only need replace that one "disk" to get back the capacity you had. Unlike an SSD, where if the SSD goes down, you have to replace the whole SSD. No data recovery option there, either.

Personally, I think this is a great idea, it's just a shame the cost for the SDHC cards isn't lower. Still, get some 133x (Or higher) cards in there and you'll have a "Drive" that has 0ms random-access time AND massive bandwidth, the holy grail of storage. Stick your Windows partition on that, and store all your media on a 1TB 5400 RPM drive, and your storage won't be the bottleneck anymore.
Quote Scottyman 13th August 2008, 06:16
I'd be interested if it was in P2 presentation, as this isn't quite flexible enough yet... looks like it's taking steps toward it - ideal for broadcast media
Quote Xir 13th August 2008, 06:37
"I'm afraid that you'll have to find another use for those hundreds of 512MB and 1GB cards that seem to accumulate every time you buy a new gadget."

Uhhh my Gadgets are officially limited to 1 GB ;-)
The three devices that do use SD cards (camera, car stereo and navigator) all state that they don't support more than one GB...never tested this though.
Quote Xir 13th August 2008, 10:21
...so if you have hundreds of spare 512 and 1GB cards... I'd take them for the car stereo :-D
Log in

You are not logged in, please login with your forum account below. If you don't already have an account please register to start contributing.







Mobile Phones

LG Arena ReviewHTC Magic Review

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!



Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 broadband & mobile broadband deals online!