Posted at 10:26 by Antony Leather with 23 comments
I blogged recently about the fact that while I hate Apple, I was considering acquiring the new iPhone 3GS. The reasons for this was that I wanted something a bit lighter and easier to use than my HTC TyTN II which sported Windows Mobile 6.1. Well, I’ve now owned a 3GS for just over a week and in short, it’s everything I wanted and more.
However I’m not going to jump headfirst into some crazy Apple love-fest spiel and no, it’s not because I still hate Apple (which I do), nor is because I got the phone for free and have been paid to (neither of which are true). It’s because I’ve come from using what was meant to be the pinnacle of the iPhone’s competition and instead I’m left wandering what the hell Microsoft and Nokia for that matter have been doing for the last few years.
Now first I’ll say that most of the things the iPhone can do, other devices can do. In fact the latest HTC handsets such as the HTC Touch HD can do more such as play a greater range of audio and video files as well as sporting higher resolution screens. They can run all manner of applications and until last weekend the iPhone didn’t have a true turn-by-turn sat nav application (it now does with Navigon MobileNavigator) while there were plenty available for Windows Mobile and Symbian, with GPS enabled Nokia handsets even coming with Nokia Maps as standard.

The HTC Touch HD is one of the iPhone's main competitors but it doesn't come close to being as slick and easy to use although it does boast a higher resolution screen.
They can also surf the Internet but while Mobile Internet Explorer isn’t worth the storage space it takes up, I’ll cut a little slack here as Opera Mobile improves things no end.

Navigon's MobileNavigator is the first true turn by turn sat nav app for the iPhone
So why is the iPhone so good? While it can also do these things it adds one massively important thing to the equation – it does them well. Very well. In fact every task I’ve undertaken from playing videos and music, surfing the Internet to taking photos and video, even using maps, contacts, calculator and a handful of third party apps, has been so perfectly polished and are so easy to use and responsive that I've been able to master the device in a few hours. It’s a pleasure to use when typing, especially with the landscape touchscreen keyboard, miles better than the slide out monstrosity on my TyTN II. Also as it's so popular there are thousands of accessories from slide on extended batteries to docking speaker systems.
Despite having used it solidly for what must be more than 20 hours, it hasn’t crashed or locked up either, something Windows Mobile did frequently on several different custom firmware’s I tried. I would even go as far as saying it feels like using an OS after a fresh install – it responds instantly to commands and clicks.
While I've yet to master iTunes, synchronising hasn’t been too challenging. I’ve even found a brilliant application called iPlayer Downloader that saves BBC iPlayer streams allowing you to simply import the file in iTunes and transfer it
I knew the iPhone was good but I didn't think the 3GS would turn out to be so stageringly useful and easy to use. There is quite literally an application for everything now so whether you want to watch videos, play music, check the tube train arrivals at any station or use it as a Sat Nav or even as a leveller, there are applications for this.
In addition, Apple has added a few things to the 3GS that makes it even better than the 3G including more RAM and a faster CPU that really do make it much nippier. There's also a digital compass which is starting to make a big difference to quite a few applications - Maps for example, rotates the view to the direction you're facing. In addition the touch screen has received a coat of oleophobic polymer which greatly reduces finger print smudging.

I've been after an all-in-one device since before the Nokia N95 was released. The idea of being able to have an MP3 player, video recorder, digital camera and a phone all in one device was a dream. Having given up on this quest, I suddenly realised that at last I have it. The iPhone 3GS does practically everything, and it does it well and every other device is left playing a huge game of catchup in at least one area. The likes of Microsoft, HTC and Nokia have a lot of work to do.
However I’m not going to jump headfirst into some crazy Apple love-fest spiel and no, it’s not because I still hate Apple (which I do), nor is because I got the phone for free and have been paid to (neither of which are true). It’s because I’ve come from using what was meant to be the pinnacle of the iPhone’s competition and instead I’m left wandering what the hell Microsoft and Nokia for that matter have been doing for the last few years.
Now first I’ll say that most of the things the iPhone can do, other devices can do. In fact the latest HTC handsets such as the HTC Touch HD can do more such as play a greater range of audio and video files as well as sporting higher resolution screens. They can run all manner of applications and until last weekend the iPhone didn’t have a true turn-by-turn sat nav application (it now does with Navigon MobileNavigator) while there were plenty available for Windows Mobile and Symbian, with GPS enabled Nokia handsets even coming with Nokia Maps as standard.

The HTC Touch HD is one of the iPhone's main competitors but it doesn't come close to being as slick and easy to use although it does boast a higher resolution screen.
They can also surf the Internet but while Mobile Internet Explorer isn’t worth the storage space it takes up, I’ll cut a little slack here as Opera Mobile improves things no end.

Navigon's MobileNavigator is the first true turn by turn sat nav app for the iPhone
So why is the iPhone so good? While it can also do these things it adds one massively important thing to the equation – it does them well. Very well. In fact every task I’ve undertaken from playing videos and music, surfing the Internet to taking photos and video, even using maps, contacts, calculator and a handful of third party apps, has been so perfectly polished and are so easy to use and responsive that I've been able to master the device in a few hours. It’s a pleasure to use when typing, especially with the landscape touchscreen keyboard, miles better than the slide out monstrosity on my TyTN II. Also as it's so popular there are thousands of accessories from slide on extended batteries to docking speaker systems.
Despite having used it solidly for what must be more than 20 hours, it hasn’t crashed or locked up either, something Windows Mobile did frequently on several different custom firmware’s I tried. I would even go as far as saying it feels like using an OS after a fresh install – it responds instantly to commands and clicks.
While I've yet to master iTunes, synchronising hasn’t been too challenging. I’ve even found a brilliant application called iPlayer Downloader that saves BBC iPlayer streams allowing you to simply import the file in iTunes and transfer it
I knew the iPhone was good but I didn't think the 3GS would turn out to be so stageringly useful and easy to use. There is quite literally an application for everything now so whether you want to watch videos, play music, check the tube train arrivals at any station or use it as a Sat Nav or even as a leveller, there are applications for this.
In addition, Apple has added a few things to the 3GS that makes it even better than the 3G including more RAM and a faster CPU that really do make it much nippier. There's also a digital compass which is starting to make a big difference to quite a few applications - Maps for example, rotates the view to the direction you're facing. In addition the touch screen has received a coat of oleophobic polymer which greatly reduces finger print smudging.

I've been after an all-in-one device since before the Nokia N95 was released. The idea of being able to have an MP3 player, video recorder, digital camera and a phone all in one device was a dream. Having given up on this quest, I suddenly realised that at last I have it. The iPhone 3GS does practically everything, and it does it well and every other device is left playing a huge game of catchup in at least one area. The likes of Microsoft, HTC and Nokia have a lot of work to do.




Comments (23)
Discuss in the forumsBut... My fiancée bought a 3GS on Friday and i have been extremely impressed with it. Its very slick and the way it handles the internet and video sources like you tube and iplayer is sublime.
I've got TwitterFon, Facebook and a TVGuide app and a couple of games installed on it and the difference compared to my old phone (which I've still got on a 3 Pay £0 contract for Skype and MSN) is staggering.
I looked at a few of the popular phones out there before finaly deciding to get one and really didn't like the feel of the equivelent Nokia/SE/LG models
I'm tempted to get the Cycle Routes app for when I get into cycling properly -which is like a sat nav (with cycle routes) crossed with a cycle computer (judges speed/distance/altitude/calories burned etc...).
Can anyone suggest a good MSN compatible Messenger app?
but im very disappointed at Apple's decision to exclude any bluetooth feature from iPhone 2G even when 2G and 3G's bluetooth hardware is exactly the same.
same goes for MMS on 2G. which i have managed to enable on my 2G.
I wouldn't mind one, but I'm tied to my contract for another year or so.
I've also used Maps as a stop gap sat nav for two hours in my car and again it was fine (battery lasted all that time too!) I'm guessing the people who have reported this either have dodgy examples or were using them in rediculous temperatures. After all, how many phones out there can you get in white? Not many so it's difficult to say if this is a 3GS specific issue or whether most phones in it's place would suffer the same issue. Either way, for people in warm countries it's a bit worrying.
@mclean007. I've been really impressed with the camera but agreed it's no way near compact status and most Nokia's etc, especially those with flash are also better. In daylight it's brilliant though - have a look at my flickr account (link in forum signature) - I took some pics last week of my Lian Li V2000 - outside the results are great and in low light it's not too bad either.
So is the inability of being able to use any track you have on it as a ring tone (you can create a ringtone in iTunes from a track you've purchased, but I kept getting an error whenever I tried it, and in any case the track I want to use is not available on iTunes even if I wanted to purchase it).
1) iTunes. Steve Jobs once called iTunes for Windows "A glass of ice water in hell"..Steve, I think you've got it backwards. Your product is one of the slowest and most bloated pieces of software in existence and has caused more problems than I can count on my fingers.
2) Non-removable battery. self-explanatory
3) No multitasking. I don't understand the point of a smartphone that can't run more than one app at once.
4) In the US, AT&T. They're almost universally hated and iPhone owners consider the worst thing about their phone is the carrier. Plus I have Verizon and won't be switching any time soon (also one of the best carriers in the country)
5) Only apps from the app store. I don't need Apple to be my mommy and tell me what's inappropriate, I can do it myself thanks.
It does seem like more issues are fixed with each iPhone revision, but I doubt they'll all ever be fixed. It's too bad because there's lots of developer support behind it.
Agreed about iTunes though. Such a crock of crap compared to how easy the actual iPhone is to use. I think the answer is to jailbreak the phone because then you can use apps that make syncing much easier and you have access to more apps too.
Apple says the battery isn't replaceable but it is possible to do it and the batteries are available. You just need to know where and how!
using it on 3GS will be fantastic, the extra free RAM......
it's great for things like: WunderRadio, iPocketTV (downloads TV shows, so background it and go to other stuff), Skype, Palringo (MSN). or any app that you want to quickly switch back to (probably won't be a problem for 3Gspeed)
I bloody hate itunes :(
Ditto
http://i-funbox.com/
iPhone browser without jailbreak!
copy music/video off iphone not possible yet, probably due to itune 8.2's new DLL hooks. but everything else works great.
I'll go for open source any day. Besides, I have Android on a laptop here, I can try out anything on it too. Now do THAT with your iPhone.
@KayinBlack
The G1 is nice, but it doesn't even compare to the iPhone 3GS in terms of speed. The 3GS can load webpages from WiFi in less than half the time, and panning and zooming around a large webpage is far easier and faster with the iPhone.
Carriers and availability not considered, the 3GS is a far better device than the G1 for everyone but an open source zealot.
That said, as a developer I love the idea of Android, and I think with some time to mature and better hardware, it will be an excellent system.